Hardy House Views: 1904 – 2025

© Mark Hertzberg (2025)

Today I had the rare (and arguably unfortunate) opportunity to photograph Frank Lloyd Wright’s Thomas P. Hardy House in Racine, Wisconsin from the lake, without getting wet. Climate change is playing havoc with Lake Michigan (as it is with the world). In 2020, the water level was so high that the stewards of the house, and neighbors, had massive hunks of stone brought in to protect their property:

IMG_5706.jpg

Today, well, I was able to walk out onto what had been part of the lake:

LR Hardy Below 2.9.25 008a.jpg

The photograph below, taken through the two story living room windows, shows how much the water has receded:

LR Hardy Below 2.9.25 029.jpg

Taking my photographs today gave me the idea to show this view of the house through the years, in historic drawings and photos. First, we have Marion Mahony’s drawing, reproduced in House Beautiful magazine’s 1906 story about the house:

House Beautiful 2.jpg© 2025 Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation, Scottsdale, AZ. The Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation Archives (The Museum of Modern Art | Avery Architectural & Fine Arts Library, Columbia University, New York)

Then we have the earliest known photograph of the house, taken in 1906, as it neared completion:

Terrace 0506.004 raw.jpg

A 1908 photograph from the OA + D archives, shows significant growth of trees on the hill:

LR 1908 Hardy HIll.jpg

The dining room terrace, which ended in a stucco wall, was demolished after World War II at the behest of the Sporers, second stewards of the house. There was a public beach, the 14th Street Beach, just south of the house (to the left of it in these drawings and photographs, until the 1970s. The Sporers asked Wright to give them a recreation room under the dining room terrace. Edgar Tafel sketched plans on Mahony’s drawing before leaving the Taliesin Fellowship in 1941. The work was not done until after the war. Full-length windows, including a door, opened to the outside:

Terrace sketch PPT.jpg© 2025 Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation, Scottsdale, AZ. The Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation Archives (The Museum of Modern Art | Avery Architectural & Fine Arts Library, Columbia University, New York), from Jim and Margaret Yoghourtjian’s collection

Next, is from David Archer’s collection. He grew up in the house between 1947 – 1957:

Archer Terrace 14.jpg

Schuyler and Peterkin Seward were stewards of the house from 1957 – 1963:

Seward Beach.jpg

Jim and Margaret Yoghourtjian were the final stewards (1968 – 2012) before the late Gene Szymczak who bought, and rehabilitated the house in 2012. Margaret took these photos:

LR Below hill horiz 2.jpg

LR Below hill main.jpg

The beach was lost in the 1970s when the City of Racine closed off a breakwater across from the house. Jim Yoghourtjian told me that they lost about 125 feet of property when the lake filled in below the house. While the Yoghourtjians used to share the house with interested parties, as they sensed people were taking them for granted and not respecting that they lived in a private home, rather than a public site, they let the landscape grow wild, to shield them from boaters on the lake and people walking the lakeshore:

LR Landscape Before 001.jpg

LR Landscape Before 004.jpg

A week after buying the house, Szymczak had the hill cleared:

LR Tree cutting 010.jpg

LR Tree cutting 047.jpg

And that, brings us to today:

LR Hardy Below 2.9.25 024.jpg

LR Hardy Below 2.9.25 011.jpg

There is no telling what the lake will do next.

 

 

Updates: Tower Tumult; Ann MacGregor

© Mark Hertzberg (2025)

Tower Tumult: On August 14 I posted about the critical situation facing Frank Lloyd Wright’s Price Tower in Bartlesville, Oklahoma (I do not know why the URL mentions the unrelated SC Johnson Research Tower). The post includes a variety of photos of Price Tower:

https://wrightinracine.net/tag/sc-johnson-research-tower/

Oklahoma Frank Lloyd Wright Price Tower 002.jpg

On January 16 a judge ordered that utilities (heat) be restored to the building. On January 21 he ordered the sale to a responsible party from Tulsa that is known for their restoration of an historic hotel there. On January 22 the current owners filed for bankruptcy. They have still not turned the utilities back on, and so this saga drags on. The question of Wright artifacts from the building that were given to an auction house in Dallas, in spite of an easement prohibiting that has not been resolved, either. Among the heroes in this story are the staff and legal counsel of the Frank Lloyd Wright Building Conservancy. Their continuing updates on the story are at:

https://savewright.org/endangered-price-tower-in-bartlesville-oklahoma/

The Building Conservancy is going deep, deep into their funds set aside for legal work as the battle to save the building drags on. Please don’t let the sunset on the building, as I literally did when I took this photograph in 2014. Hint: they would welcome your financial support at:

https://savewright.org/give/

Remembering Ann MacGregor: On November 23 I posted a tribute to the late Ann MacGregor, one of the heroes in Mason City, Iowa’s successful quest to save Wright’s only extant hotel commission, the then-dilapidated Park Inn Hotel and adjoining City National Bank building. The hotel is now a successful boutique hotel:

https://wrightinracine.net/2024/11/23/remembering-ann-macgregor/

LR Pre-dinner 012.jpgAnn MacGregor with Scott Perkins of the Frank Lloyd Wright Building Conservancy, 2012

My tribute to Ann mentioned her long-term correspondence with Marshall Jones, a friend of mine, who is serving two consecutive life terms for homicide in Wisconsin. He became interested in Wright after I interviewed him for a project about the criminal justice system.

LR Marshall Jones Waupun 014.jpg

I wrote Marshall to tell him about Ann’s passing, and sent him a copy of my story. He wrote me back last week (mail to the prison system faces interminable delays while it is sent to a place in Maryland that copies incoming letters and then sends the copies to inmates) with his own tribute to Ann:

“I appreciate you for sending me the news of Ann’s passing. A part of me was deeply saddened, but another part of me was greatly appreciative that I had the privilege of being considered her friend, She was so much more than someone that I corresponded with. She was someone who brought unconditional love, unconditional positive regard, she allowed me to peer into her beautiful family, and she gave me priceless guidance. She didn’t see me by my conviction, nor did she allow me to accept my worst decision as the resounding theme for my life. She was ruthless when it came to goals, and when you said that you wanted to accomplish something, she pressed you until it was done. She was amazingly supportive and she encouraged me with gentleness and love. You knew that Ann had your back. We talked about Mr. Wright, religion (we were both Christians), politics, family, and life. Her disposition increased in positivism even in the face of diminishing health. So, I am grateful for her life, and for her presence in my life. I was so blessed by her, and I am better because of her friendship. It was much deeper than correspondence. With Ann and Bruce (Bruce Brooks Pfeiffer also corresponded with Marshall), I was family. I now carry her with me everywhere I go.”

Well, Marshall, my story was more of the nuts and bolts of her life, as we used to say in the newsroom. You captured her essence. Thank you.