© Mark Hertzberg (2024)
In print, on a phone, on a tablet, on a television screen…it doesn’t matter what the medium, as modern media constantly bombards us with countless images. We are immune to most of them. Just a small handful of still photographs stop us in our tracks. We were reminded of that recently after the attempted assassination of former president Donald Trump. Such are the moments in history that we remember because of a still photograph. Is that the case in the World of Wright?
There are umpteen photographs of Frank Lloyd Wright’s completed buildings. What sticks in my mind today, however, is an arresting photograph of Wright’s Frederick C. Robie House. It is not another same-old, same-old photo of the house. Rather, it is one of Wright’s ship-like, Prairie-style house at 58th and Woodlawn in Chicago’s Hyde Park neighborhood under construction in the summer of 1909.
Photograph courtesy of Eric M. O’Malley, from his private collection
This photograph stopped me in my tracks when I was reading the latest issue of “OA+D,” the Journal of Organic Architecture and Design. Each issue is devoted to a single topic, in this case the Robie House. Wright scholar Kathryn Smith gives readers a definitive account of the history and architectural significance of the house, “Space was no longer static, but dynamic. It was a revolutionary new idea, and one that would profoundly change 20th century architecture in the decades ahead.” Her article is richly illustrated with drawings from the Wasmuth portfolio, and historic and contemporary photographs. There are about 30 construction photos taken between April 1909 and April 1910, mostly by Harrison Bernard Barnard.
I found this one particularly striking. I was mesmerized. It reminded me of something Wright scholar Jonathan Lipman wrote to me when I was writing my book about Wright’s Thomas P. Hardy House, “One can get a sense of its impact in 1906 Racine by imagining if, instead, a swooping, curved titanium house by Frank Gehry were built on the site a century later.” What, indeed, did people in Hyde Park think when they saw this rising in their neighborhood?
With no television to distract them after dinner, did neighbors regularly stroll after supper, making it a point to pass by the odd house rising at 58th and Woodlawn? Were they struck, as I was by this photograph, or did they murmur in disapproval? Although Wright and Mamah Borthwick (Cheney) would not leave for Europe together until the fall of 1909, had word of their affair traveled from Oak Park to Hyde Park? Was this odd house then a confirmation of prejudices people might have had against a man who was upending social mores? Or were they progressive thinkers, perhaps people who taught at the nearby University of Chicago which opened in 1892, who were excited and intrigued by what they were seeing on that corner lot?
The house had been rising for several months when this photograph from Eric M. O’Malley’s private collection was taken in the summer of 1909. The superstructure of the house is almost complete. We have a sense of what the house will look like, but it is still a mystery in many respects. For example, we see only empty spaces where magnificent leaded glass windows will be installed. I think it is that sense of mystery, of the unknown, that excited me.
Robie was built 16 years after the World’s Columbian Exposition in nearby Jackson Park. Only Louis Sullivan’s Transportation Building had broken the fair’s landscape of one Classical Revival-style building after another. Wright’s Heller, Blossom and McArthur houses are nearby , but are not as startling as Robie would have been in 1909. Rockefeller Chapel nearby at the University of Chicago would not be built until 1928, and it would be a traditional Gothic design, reinforcing the startling design of Robie, perched on its corner lot. Startling and groundbreaking, indeed.
As I thought about this article for a month or more, the photograph of Robie brought to mind one more Wright construction photo. It is of the SC Johnson Research Tower in Racine. The Tower was designed in 1943/44, and built between November 1947 and November 1950. It is Wright’s only realized taproot tower.* This photograph reminded me of a child’s stacking toy when I ran across it in Johnson’s archives when I was writing my book at the Research Tower in 2009. What, then, did people living near 1525 Howe Street in Racine (two miles from my home) think when this began rising above their traditional houses?
Photograph courtesy of SC Johnson Archives
Dozens of books have been published with photographs of Wright’s finished work. The late Sam Johnson, whose father H.F. Johnson Jr. commissioned the SC Johnson Administration Building, the Research Tower, and Wingspread, among others (unrealized), remarked to me “The world does not need another book about Frank Lloyd Wright.”** Perhaps it needs one comprised soley of photographs of his buildings under construction.
P.S. I think Eric O’Malley was also dazzled by the photograph…it appears twice in the magazine, the first time as a chapter title page.
Footnotes:
*The late Bruce Brooks Pfeiffer, who wrote the Foreword to my book about the Research Tower, told me that although Price Tower looks like a taproot tower, it is not one because it is tied into the foundation of the adjoining two-story office building. He said Racine was Wright’s only realized taproot tower.
**The context for Johnson’s remark was that I was pitching my idea for a book which became my “Wright in Racine” book (Pomegranate: 2004). The rest of his observation was, “…but it does need one about his work in Racine.” I was elated and treated myself to a Dove ice cream bar after leaving our meeting.
Link to OA+D store and Robie issue of the Journal:
https://store.oadarchives.org/product/journal-oa-d-v12-n1
Please scroll down for previous articles on this blog
SC Johnson Administration Building, Racine (1936)
Roland and Ronny working with Wright on the design of their Wright home
Roland was honored as a founding member of the Frank Lloyd Wright Building Conservancy by Janet Halstead and Richard Longstreth at the 2014 conference in Phoenix.
The Reisley House was the topic of a discussion at the 2014 conference. Susan Jacobs Lockhart moderated.
Roland and Neil Levine chat at the conference.
Roland and Ginny Kazor at the Phoenix conference.
Roland greets conference attendees in his living room during the 2017 conference.
Barbara and Roland, 2011
Mr. and Mrs. Wright and their guests sat in the seats to the right.
From Wright’s “An Autobiography:” When I was a small child I used to lie awake listening to the strains of the Sonata Pathetique—Father playing it on the Steinway square downstairs in the Baptist minister’s house at Weymouth. It takes me back to boyhood again when I hear it now.” [FLLW: Collected Writings, v. 4, p. 147.]
The Buddha statues will be put back in their original places flanking the stage.
A dining chair from Taliesin (c. 1925) frames a view of the library table for the Edward C. Waller House Remodeling (1899).
The library table, in turn, frames the Taliesin chair and an “origami chair” from Taliesin West (1946).
Hanging lamp, William R. Heath House (c. 1905) – the lines are distorted by the camera angle.
Minerva, her daughter, Margo, and son, Andrew
There was a video slide show
Granddaughter Divina Allan and great-granddaughter Eliza Harry-Ray, 4
Olivia Dubson, a special friend of Minerva’s
Margo reads from Minerva’s baby book…Minerva, a surprise twin, was late, setting the stage for a lifetime habit, Margo said with a chuckle.
Indira Berndtson
Yes, Happy B/day Minerva! Indeed!
Safina Uberoi – photo courtesy of Safina Uberoi
Lukas Ruecker at the Bagley House
Lukas Ruecker, right, and Safina Uberoi with Jeff and Jeannette, Goldstone, the previous owners of the Bagley House – photo courtesy of Safina Uberoi
Some of the original siding is under the aluminum siding.
Before the aluminum siding was put on – Courtesy Hinsdale Historical Society
The addition to the rear of the house will be taken off.
Safina Uberoi with Jay Deguchi and George Suyama – Photo courtesy of Safina Uberoi
The “Finding Grace” exhibit at the Bagley House
The Stephen Foster Cottage
The Mitchell House in 1895 – 
The Bagley House library
Wright in Racine 